Of God and Nature - Interview with Stephen C Meyer
Famed author and scientific philosopher Stephen C. Meyer joins us to discuss new genetic research which supports intelligent design theory. We also discuss mind, Natural Law and secularism impact on contemporary science. It’s a fascinating discussion.
For more information on Stephen’s works go to: stephencmeyer.org
0:00 It's good to have you here and I appreciate you joining me. My, my, this is something that I'm into completely. I've always been a big believer in the intelligent design hypothesis and clearly you are as well. Let me introduce you to my audience, Stephen C Meyer has received a PhD in the philosophy of science from the University of Cambridge, a former geophysicist and college professor. He now directs discovery institute's Center for Science, and culture in Seattle and addition to two Myers landmarks book. The New York Times bestselling Darwin's doubt the explosive origin of animal life, and the case for intelligent design and the book signature of in the cell DNA and the evidence for intelligent design. And then of course, the peer-reviewed volume Darwinism design and public education published in 2004, Michigan State University.
1:00 And explore Evolution also published in 2007. So it is clear, has it always been the case? Stephen, that you are a proponent of intelligent design, always, or did it happen? Because of some discovery that you had? Well, it has I first became interested in the idea in the mid 80s when I was a very young scientist. I attended a conference in Dallas where I was working. I was working at the time as a geophysicist doing what was called Digital Signal processing which is an early form of Information Technology and I attended a conference on the origin of life and the origin of the universe to great big subjects that intersect science and philosophy and discovered listening to a very spirited discussion on a panel between proponents of what was then not really even called. And design it was just a very nascent idea that there must be some sort of intelligent cause that played a role in the origin of life.
2:08 On the one hand and on the other there were proponents of a strictly chemical evolutionary theory proposed that you could explain the origin of the first life as a result of undirected chemical processes and both sides in the discussion agreed. That the problem of the origin of the first life had not been solved, there wasn't an adequate chemical evolutionary theory and the big Do they both recognize both sides, recognize was the origin of the information that's stored in DNA and other large called bio macromolecules, things like RNA and proteins, and that on the one side that the proponents of the chemical evolutionary approach, that hey, give us more time.
2:50 We'll figure this out. And on the other side, the scientists were saying, well, wait a minute isn't information. Typically a product of mind. At that point, I got really intrigued, maybe what we're looking at at the foundation of life in the code that stored in the DNA, the digital code that stored is actually evidence of a designing intelligence. And so, I ended entered into some fascinating conversations with some of the scientists I met at that conference who are proponents of this idea that later became known as the theory of intelligent design or the evidence for intelligent design. I went to grad school and Cambridge for four years, did a PhD on origin of Life biology. And by the time I finished that I was pretty convinced that we were in fact, looking at evidence of design in the cell. And so I think sometime in the late 80s, early 90s, I became convinced of intelligent design and I've been working on it ever since.
3:44 It's interesting because in philosophy classes that I took in college particularly around 1991, there was a lot of discussion about intelligent design, creationism versus random causation, and It was always a sticking point that it seemed to me even then that science was hesitant to embrace any notion of intelligent design because it it almost gives Credence to the idea of a God or an all-powerful and you'd have to be an all-powerful Creator. In order to design such a complex living organism as the universe with all of its anticipated. So how is it that science can.
4:29 Bill with a straight face assume hypothetically that random causation is how we got here by accident? How can they how can they put Faith in that kind of? You know, there is a sometimes unspoken but sometimes spoken rule of method but many scientists adhere to and regard as effectively normative for them and that rule has a name it's called methodological naturalism. And it states, simply that if you're going to explain something scientifically, you must limit yourself to strictly materialistic. Explanations those based on chance or Randomness as you mentioned, or other types of materialistic explanation such as natural laws or undirected processes like natural selection.
5:19 The problem with that rule though is that in many in many Realms of science, it's not a problematic rule first, I should say that. Because in many Realms of science are just asking, how does one part of nature, affect another part and questions of that form, give rise naturally to questions about what nature is doing on its own unassisted by intelligence. But if you're asking questions about causal Origins, and ultimate causal, Origins questions about the origin of the first life, or questions about the origin of the universe, or questions about how the universe acquired. Its finely-tuned structure. An answer might be Adequate answer might involve only undirected material processes but the right answer might also involve the idea of creative intelligence that may be a mind played a role in some of the features in the origin of some of the features that we see in life for the universe.
6:14 And so if you close yourself off from that possibility, ah, priori before you have any experience before, you've even examined the data you may be, you may end up because of your rule of method, missed the Answer, you may not get the best explanation. You may only get the best explanation among an artificially limited set of materialistic possibilities. And so, one of the things we've been doing, in the intelligent design, research Community is not only looking at the evidence striking, evidence of design in life and the universe and our planetary system and other other parts of nature. But also challenging that rule of method and suggesting that we need to have a more open philosophy of science that allows us to consider the best explanation, whatever, whether it conforms to those materialistic sensibilities or not.
7:06 And and so much of my work has actually been involved with challenging. The rule of method known as methodological naturalism and showing that it's it's intellectually limiting for the scientist and really, we want to follow the evidence and come up with the best explanation. No-holds-barred is one of Michael. Yeah. So, and and so, where did this come from? I've done some reading on the early, Enlightenment, Enlightenment period, the Age of Reason, if you will, and it seemed to me more of a reaction to the overbearing Church, they there was such an attempt to get away from the grips of this Authority authoritative and clergy that, you know, we all know the story of Galileo and Copernicus, and a lot of these early scientists were actually excommunicated because of their Views of a solar system instead of an earth Centrist universe. So was was the secularism that was part of the early fabric of science.
8:08 A reaction to distance itself from religion. Well, I think there was a movement in philosophy. Actually, when you mentioned the tone, is The Enlightenment, the famous movement in philosophy which was an attempt to establish the legitimacy of human reason, apart from divine revelation and and a separation of reason and Revelation, although there were theistic and Christian versions of the Enlightenment as well. So it was not a unitary kind of movement, but there was a very secular Emphasis in some parts of or in some some Enlightenment thinkers and in as that if began to that began to affect science in the 19th century.
8:53 And there was a, there's a famous philosopher named August comped, his argued that science is it progresses goes through three stages. There's a theological stage, which is essentially mythological, he thought you know, invoking God's and Thunderbolts and that sort of thing and then there's a Philosophical stage. There he exemplified by people like Aristotle and Plato with Concepts like the forms or things like that. And then there's a positive stage where we explain everything by reference to Natural laws. And that's the scientific stage. And so science in the way he defined. It necessarily must extricate itself from theological superstitions and explain everything. By reference to undirected material processes in Laws of nature Darwin was very much influenced by comped and in the Origin of Species.
9:50 You saw this for the first time or one of the first times, this kind of intentional rhetorical strategy of defining, any explanation by reference to creative intelligence, or mind or design, or God as an unscientific explanation. So in Darwin was looking at a phenomenon known as homology, the similarity of structure in different organisms, Morphological structure. He said, well, you know, there is this other explanation idea that the similarity is the result of divine, Divine or design, but he said, but he says, but that's not a scientific explanation, though.
10:33 Acknowledged that it could explain the data, but it was not the similarity might be the result of a common design from a chronic singular intelligence, but he said that's not a scientific Nation and therefore he elected. His alternative is the only one that could really be considered. And yeah, and we've seen this rhetorical strategy now played out in these Origins questions for 160 years and intelligent design movement. As you mentioned is challenging that because there are there are very striking indicators of design in living systems, for example, that are not well, explained by undirected material processes, but are exactly the kind of thing that we know to be the case. No, to no.2 have Arisen base. On our uniform and repeated experience from the activity of intelligence.
11:16 And one of those strike most striking indicators is information, especially information, that is functional and is expressed in a digital or alphabetic form. And that's essentially what we have in living systems, Stephen Meyer is my guest, a philosopher of science, author of some incredible Works, which we'll get into it in more detail. So are we any closer to understanding how the mind before I asked you that I argued once too? Professor of religion at a university, who was an admitted atheist. I said, well, how do you? How do you explain pattern and consistency of laws are they not denoting of intelligence? Because patterns after all do indicate form and form is not accidental form is adheres to strict laws of physical science. So even in observing physical laws we observe Serve patterns that repeat at different levels, varying levels, for example, a simple drop of a, you know, a pebble in in a pond. You see?
12:23 A concentric Circle that moves out uniformly. It's not haphazard, it's not variable, it's in a uniform pattern. So, I've argued that pattern itself is a great clue to the fact that the Universe, however, it came to be and however, we came to be must have been a pre-planned event and it seems to be That there's more of an argument for that rather than random causation. Well, the early scientists Newton boil Kepler, for example, thought that what we call the laws of nature are actually an expression of divine action that the term laws of nature was as one historian has putted a juridical metaphor of theological origin. There are laws in nature.
13:14 There are these regularities because there is a law Giver or law sustainer someone who's sustaining the The orderly Concourse of Nature, and this was actually Newton's View and it was expressed in his Grand work, the principia, which was exploring the, the mathematical structure of nature, as a way of understanding the mind of God. And he wrote a theological epilogue, to the principia called, the general Schoo. Liam in which he essentially paraphrase, that passage from The book of Colossians where it says in God, all things are are held together. And so this is, this is a very venerable view of what the laws of nature are these patterns that we see these patterns of regularity now naturalist.
14:10 So naturalistically minded philosophers have said, well, the laws of nature are in essence, the ground of all being. They are the primary. See the thing that explains everything else, Sean Carroll is said that naturalism is the world view that holds that that ultimately there are. There's a series of explanations in terms of natural processes that ultimately Finds Its the Finds Its ultimate explanation in the laws of nature and then you can go no further. So, for the, the naturalistic philosophers opposed to the theistic one, the laws of nature are the ultimate explanatory. Suppose the ultimate realities and they need no further explanation.
14:54 They just are what we've been doing in the, in the intelligent design movement is showing that there's another way to detect design besides just merely pattern. And that is the idea that when you have events or systems that exhibit, both a pattern, that we know independently from some other realm of experience and that pattern is highly improbable. Improbable as it were against the backdrop of what nature ordinarily does. Then we can detect the special action of this, Divine intelligence, or of some intelligence. And so for example we often use the faces on the Mountain at Mount Rushmore is an example, there's a pattern there but it's a highly improbable in a regular pattern that you would not expect to arise based on wind and erosion or other natural processes and it's a pattern that we recognize from Pendant experience. So when we see those faces, we immediately recognized the designing intelligence must have been involved. The idea that that God is the ultimate explanation for the regularities of nature is a possible explanation, but in the case of a pattern that's also highly improbable against what natural laws typically produce, then we have an argument that is not just possible but definitely the best or the we have evidence of design is the best explanation not It possible explanation and the kind of in the other kind of indicator of design that we've identified.
16:30 That's that's decisive, is the presence of information because we know of only one known cause for information again especially as we find it in a digital or alphabetic form, and that's what we have in DNA. Bill Gates has said that DNA is like a software program but much more complex than any we've ever created. Richard Dawkins, the great scientific atheist from Great Britain has himself acknowledged that DNA contains machine code. One of our great biotech Engineers bio technicians Leroy Hood out here in Seattle has said that DNA, simply contains digital code. Well, what we know from experience is that such code always arises from a programmer and in fact, whenever we see information and we trace it back to its ultimate source, whether we're talking about A paragraph and a book or hieroglyphic inscription, or information embedded in a radio signal, or information in a computer program of some kind.
17:30 We always trace it back or come ultimately, to am I not an undirected material process. So the laws of nature May well be a product of of an underlying, The Hidden Hand of God, if you will. But when we encounter information in a In a complex functional and digital form. We have decisive evidence of intelligent design and that's that's where we've laid the stress in our work. And is this because we have become better at looking and evaluating our own DNA and how it works. And because up until recently, we that the new area of exploration, is it not DNA as well getting into the Breakthrough and yeah, thanks for asking, sorry to interrupt the, the The Breakthrough in this area of study came in the 1950s and 60s in a period that historians of science.
18:27 Now called the molecular biological Revolution, it wasn't that long ago, but Watson and Crick elucidated the structure of DNA in 1953 in 57 and 58 Creek. Propose, something he called the sequence hypothesis, which was the idea that the chemical subunits that run along the interior of the DNA molecule. If you think back to high school biology, think of that twisting, he looks right. And along the inside of that Helix there are chemical subunits called bases, that run up and down the spine of the Helix some on each side. There's what they call complementary base pairing and all that, but creek, proposed that those those subunits called basis.
19:10 Are functioning like alphabetic characters in a written text or we could say now, like the zeros and ones in a section of software which is to say that the basis do not perform their function in virtue of their chemical properties, or their shapes, or their, the mass or anything like that, or physical or chemical properties. But instead in virtue of their arrangement, in a chord with an independent symbol convention, which is similar to the nine Realms of genetic codes inside life, we have genetic code and genetic text And that's where this all began. This information based analysis of life. That's fascinating. And do would you say that having gone this far where did life or how do you feel it? Oh, by the way, I just read the other day that they have now completed the whole genetic code of humanity, right? This is something I read in where they have mapped out. The entire genome structure of the human DNA, is that? Well, I think Francis Crick first. Announced the completion.
20:10 Pleat sequencing of the human genome in 2000, and Craig Venter. Had a big hand in that there were both private and publicly funded groups working on that. And they keep making advances in categorizing, the genetic information that's contained therein. But yeah, this is a big discovery that, you know, even our human genome we've known since Watson is about the mid-60s. W are sorry since the mid-60s crick's hypothesis of the sequence. Has been well established. It was confirmed by a series of experiments on both sides of the Atlantic. It was, it was not the kind of prediction or proposal that you could, you could confirm with one simple experiment, it was really a matter of mapping out how the information in the DNA is directing the construction of the proteins and protein machines that keep cells alive. That's called the gene expression system or system for protein synthesis.
21:06 So since then we've known that crick's idea was was Essentially correct. And and then there have been a vast advances in field known as bioinformatics in which we've been able to map the genomes of of letter by letter to figure out a what's there and and and increasingly probably what you're referring to is, we're getting more and more information about what the different sections of the genome do. And we've been able to do that for scientists, have been able to do that for multiple organisms, so understanding Informational properties at the foundation of life. For many different organisms has been a big part of biology. Certainly, since since year 2000, this is exciting stuff and I know we don't have a all day because I could go all day on this one.
21:59 Let's talk about the mind for a minute is mind a physical reality. In other words? Or is it super imposed upon the mechanism of our conscience? In other, Words, it does it act independently of the material world and that's what, what do we know about the mind that we didn't know? What are the recent discoveries? We've learned about the mind. That lead you to believe that there might be a universal mind. Well, there are two different basic views of What's called the mind-body question. One is that, is that the material brain is primary and what we experience as Consciousness is a kind of epiphenomenon or byproduct of material processes, but it isn't really, no way a separate kind of reality and that everything that We experience is a very direct product of neuro physiological processes. The other view is that the rain is being used by the mind as an organ of sense and an organ of thought. And and so that the mind is, is actually the mental realm is really quite separate.
23:20 From the the material, the material substrate that does indeed make it possible. But the idea here is that the brain is a necessary, but not sufficient condition of what's taking place in the mind. We can reason because of the properties are powers of our minds. Our reasoning is not governed by the neurophysiological events that are taking place in our synapses or something. So it's not the chemistry isn't determining our thought, the chemistry makes possible the mines function, the the neurochemistry of the brain, but it's necessary. But not Efficient and that they're the Mind. Therefore has its own capabilities and - spontaneous and it deliberate it. Yeah, the most and I tend to the second view, I think in the mind and I think there's a lot of, there's actually, a lot of physiological evidence that the what's going on in the brain, cannot explain everything that's going on in the mind and the mind is using the brain.
24:19 And I think all of us have the sense that we can make choices, you know, I lift my arm. I'm putting in motion a new series of cause and effect events that and that that begin with a choice in my mind, not as a result of something that happened. In my, my brain, something happens in my brain as a result of my mental choice, but the mental is primary, and I think that's when people actually think about this deeply and are introspective about the powers of their own agency. We all are Consciously aware beings. We have an intuitive awareness of what our minds can do. We all sense that we can initiate new lines of cause and effect?
25:07 That is to say, we can make choices that make a difference in how things happen in the physical world. So there I think as counterintuitive as it is in a materialistic, scientific age to think of something immaterial, controlling, something material, I think that's actually much more Consistent with our own direct introspective experience of what mines do and what we as thinking self conscious agents and of the powers that we as self-conscious agents have, this is obviously a huge discussion, but I think they're both philosophical reasons to hold this. What's called a mind-body, duelist position and neurophysiological experiments that support the idea that the mind is not the brain and the brain is not the mind.
25:54 The mind is control. And using the brain as an organ of sense. And thought, I guess you could put it this way. You know, you've got an airplane, you've got a pilot, you've got a navigator. And the pilot seems to know where the direction it wants to head and the the airplane represents, I think the body, the physical body and it's an interesting and ongoing discussion. It's one of the reasons I like philosophy because you can discuss it from age to age and it's just fascinating. Mating Stephen C, Meyer? Dot org, is the website Steven that's stephan1. See, Meyer dot-org, the author of The Return of the god hypothesis. Also, his previous Works Darwin's doubt. And the DSL DNA, and the evidence of intelligent design and I wish I had more time.
26:44 I want to just real quickly, what were the markers in your opinion? That give give give rise to the hypothesis. That DNA was an organized structure. In other words, it was Find what were some of the markers that you found? Well it's it's the presence of the information. That's directing the protein synthesis and the use of a code to translate the information from one form into a useful form of information for the production of the proteins. And that's one of the three indicators of intelligent design in the universe as the intelligent design and life in the book. I also look at what's called the fine-tuning of the laws and constants of physics and the other Basic physical parameters that make life possible in the universe. So we see not only evidence of designer Rising long after the beginning of the universe in the first life. But we also see evidence of design in the fine-tuning of the physical parameters of the Universe. From the very beginning of the universe, which suggests a designing intelligence, which is not only active in the creation. But also must transcend, the creation must have the capability of structuring, the whole of the creation from the beginning and then the third key piece of evidence that I look at for what I call not just said intelligent design. Hi This is but the god hypothesis. God as the designer is that the universe itself, the physical Universe of matter space time and energy had a definite beginning a finite time ago before, which it would be impossible to provide a materialistic explanation because before the origin of
28:14 matter, there would be no matter to remove the ultimate causing you need something that transcends matter space time and energy is capable of initiating. A huge change of state is immensely powerful and is also intelligent enough to structure everything to Reduce Ally friendly Universe. Does that remind you of anyone exactly the argument of the book? I think I would I argue is that a theistic God, insofar as it has those necessary properties provides, the best explanation for the origin of life in the universe. And that's what I call the return of the god hypothesis. I'm sure it's great. Reading, I encourage people listening to this podcast to join. Stephen C Meyer and his journey. It's a Wonderful journey and he'll show you things.
28:56 You probably never thought about before Stephen. C, Meyer dot-org, name of the book, Return of the god hypothesis, and I thank you. It's an honor to speak with you big fan of yours and I hope we can have you on again real soon.