Byron Belitsos on Integral Theodicy and Why God Allows Evil to Exist
In part 1 of our two-part interview, Urantia student and researcher-author Byron Belitsos shares insight on his new book on how, over the past two millennia, great thinkers have attempted to explain why God allows evil to exist. Byron joins us to discuss the points of his latest book, "The Truth About Evil, Sin and the Demonic: Toward an Integral Theodicy."
0:00 Welcome to another great episode of the Rancho Radio podcast. I am very excited to have on the program Byron, boletos who has written a great new book, which I've had the pleasure of reading, and it's entitled truths about evil sin. And the Demonic toward an intrical theodicy, Byron boletos joining us. Don't forget. You can always check us out online. Your aunt, your radio dotnet, and we appreciate you sharing these podcast with your friends and thanks for joining us. Byron Millet says is my guest and he has written a seminal book, will talk about called truths about evil sin, and the Demonic Byron has been with us. Numerous times also wrote your evolving Soul, which I highly recommend it also delves into the evil concept original sin. But today, we're going to talk about something called The Odyssey, which is the ongoing philosophical and Theological debate over God's influence on Humanity. Why evil is allowed to exist at all and Questions that theologians through the ages of grappled with. Why does God allow evil is evil?
1:06 A real construct, all of which Byron addresses in his latest book Byron has also been reading the ranch of look for decades and continues to give lectures and seminars pertaining to the revelations teachings. And we are honored to have Byron on the program in this very candid interview, five years, huh? Five years, Carla fought about five years ago when I decided to leave the west coast and go to A seminary, I was 2018, and I sort of knew that this would be the issue for me to studying theology, since I just grew up, so sensitive to, you know, the problem of evil. So, yeah, it's five years. So, I started writing little papers, little kind of parts of the book were papers.
1:48 I wrote for classes and and so I was getting a getting some momentum with it in these small papers and then suddenly it came together that, oh, yeah. The you be Really addresses the key issues that theology has been grappling with in this regard and I vaguely. I mean, I knew that but once you read these things, like st. St. Augustine, or Aquinas, or the modern theologians. They're dealing with the same issues that the Urantia book does when it talks about evil and good. So it's not like, you know, the ranch which is popped out of nowhere. You know, it's in a big con.
2:29 For Sation with this huge tradition and you take us through this history. It's cuz it did it all come together naturally or how long did it take you to write it and then how many times did you rewrite it? Right. Well, you're cute. I had to write a master's thesis to do so after the second year or you write the thesis, so I took maybe three months to write it and was a short version of this book, The, but it Delia You write something like that. And you think, well, I still got, you know, 50 other books I wanted to read and I still want to, you know, drill down on this issue or that issue, and it's just lingered around. And so, it really, you know, people, when I had an opening was in a kind of a contract job with a non-profit one that ran out, I just took the time to try to rewrite everything about Ten times.
3:31 Yeah so let's dig into that a little bit. So first of all we since you were so eloquent, tell us about the theodicy and why it's so important to this discussion that we have about God and freedom of Will and an evil and horrendous evil, tell us how theodicy sort of intertwines these three further mind when I said theodicy thought I was talking about home. Or, you know, the Odyssey and The Iliad, so it's not Homer, it's see, Odyssey and the D. I see why in the end is sort of making god making Gower exonerating God in the face of evil, and it is pretty much common sense, right? It's it's whatever.
4:20 But every person of faith is mainly struggling with is in a, why do I have so much anguish and so much, you know, sort of perpetration that You see why is God allowing all of this? And is God really there for me and for us and so I mean we all have that mean even children and so he wasn't really handled in a systematic way until really later in the 17th century when the term was coined by a philosopher wideness of things lost for at the time but it was already in. Suitably there in all of the early writings and even in the Bible, even in Paul, in st. Paul specially is, you know, what do we do? How do we grapple with this, you know, this this demonic least in the biblical sense, you know, the Demonic presence and what why is God?
5:18 But but then well, okay, so God sent his only son, you know, the early Christians said, you know, and that that's kind of a theodicy because God is guessing the problem he's sending his, his son to sort of wage spiritual war against these forces demonic forces as the early Christians thought and he confronted Satan and he deposed him, you know, so these kind of activities are this very enactment of theodicy that early cringed Christian sort of saw that that you know, God's God's got our back, you know, against these forces because they were dealing with this, Really pretty violent and dark power.
6:03 You know, the Roman Empire that was a basically enslaved them the Jews. So, you know, they're reaching out for a for an answer. Is it going to be a messiah that will lead us, you know, into a new new world or World. It will be something else, right? So so, you know, the so we get the sort of the first theodicy is what we read in the Bible, and I think exemplified in the Gospel of John. John and, but it's based on this notion of a kind of a conflict and have it a war in heaven, and that's the first of seven or eight distinct versions. That I trace all the way up to Modern theology there, different Renditions of good versus evil and how good prevails, and how God is sort of defended, you know, defending God's omnipotent. So this is this this issue of omnipotence Zero critical to this because you know God is all-powerful. So you know what?
7:03 Come on. God had come and pull us out of This calamity. There were in the middle of if your all-powerful and if you really love us show us that you care and the you know providential care you but just a lot of ways to to to address it and and there are at least three distinct ways that ancient Christianity began to do theodicy as he we here today, as you mentioned, you Do many people refuse to believe in God, especially post-holocaust because they ask themselves this. Very integral question is, if there is a God, why does he allow evil to happen? A loving God would prevent and that's when you get into the theodicy, that's when you're trying to like you say, exonerate God for the evil, that is for some reason allowed to happen.
7:53 Why do we suffer all of these questions? That could come into every moral person's head and what your book? Did so eloquently, is it? It it took the various theodicies of the people down Through the Ages and how it in each generation. It was almost like everybody had their, their well-thought-out opinion of what they what they thought of the Odyssey. What does what is God's relationship? Do we really have free will is everything predetermined? If everything is predetermined? Maybe we don't have free will and that is that is the the the ongoing debate in theodicy. Well said Jim. Yeah, I think that's pretty good that, that if you see the issue of predetermination or predestination is really comes up in a huge way as another answer to this, which is that God is in control even of evil.
8:47 I mean, so evil is not really evil. It appears to be, but God is harvesting these apparently bad experiences for the good for greater good actually. And so, you know, that's, that's Not a bad concept on the surface and that Christians come up with that and they utilize that and it still is the in a way the central teaching of, you know, main lines least parts of Mainline protestantism or certainly fundamentalist protestantism. For example, let's go back to the the enlightenment, the so-called Age of Reason and and maybe even perhaps the introduction of humanism as its own theodicy because sort of where I see the the modernized secular world today.
9:33 But this really had its roots during that period of cons and other philosophers of that era who were trying to debate the existence of deity and played into, you know, the ideas of being endowed by our creator. And those are the things that some of the things that you bring up in your book. It's analogous to what happened in the 20th. Century also happened in the 17th century 20th. We do deal with the world wars. Hiroshima will back then. They had a really, really great Calamity which was the war that was set off by the Protestant revolt. And you know, a lot of us, don't really get enough instruction about that and high school college, but it was a really great disaster for the Continental Europe that which then moved over in England in the Civil War there. 17th century. It was it really made Theology and religion and the church look really bad.
10:35 So there was a Revolt of intellectuals as you just indicated and it's the same kind of Revolt that we have today, the secular revolt and back then it was well at least we have human reason and reasonable people with never countenance in a religious Warfare and and Slaughter of you know, a Protestant Spike Catholics and vice versa. So let's get rid of that and come back to the material basis of our life, you know. So then you get science and you get the sort of the basic principles of Enlightenment philosophy, which is real law, natural law.
11:18 So, so rather than this spiritual law, which we get these, you know, these priesthoods that are, you know, telling us about these spiritual principles, but but we have now, we have The ability to measure nature with reason and with mathematics and, and, and what do we need these people there, because we can create a better world through science really through rationality. So that becomes in a way of theodicy or a substitute for theodicy. Yeah, tell me. Who is it Peckham the the Contemporary philosopher religionist that you spoke of who you mentioned came very close or has very similar.
11:59 Use on the Odyssey to the Urantia book, so who was Pepe? Oh yeah, great, yeah, John Peckham, you know? You when you when you look at the literature you find the outstanding books on this and he was really perhaps the best I've seen by few theodicy, cysts by philosophers of religion and he is more on the conservative side is actually a Seventh-Day Adventist. But they're very, very high level of philosophically trained Theologian at the very Apex of of fat of that church teaching their semin being Seminary.
12:42 So he really picked up a lot of threads to that the ranch a book has put together already but he put it together through couple decades of research that there must be. You know, the Bible talks about, you know, the devil and the devil's presence. But there's got to be these mitigating factors that explains why Jesus did not really put an end to the preface to this full. So rebellious, Angel presence, and we have a Mythic framing of it in the Bible but let's do it. Let's do a philosophic framing. Now that we're, you know, in the postmodern age, how would we look at that as a philosopher?
13:24 It's a theologian. And so he shows basically what the Rancher book feels. In which is there had to have been this prior agreement with the satanic forces which allowed them to remain on the planet, even after the Incarnation of Christ and for them to operate in this kind of modify way and and that that they would not be adjudicated immediately. Although their powers had been had been stripped from them, they still could operate. So it's basically a lot like what the ranch ebook That and he's just inferring it logically from from what we see. No, no way that he would have had any connection with the Urantia book or anything like that, right? Not aware of it.
14:10 No evidence that he did. He did. In fact, I did write to him and, you know, praised his work and I asked him if he would meet with me at the American Academy of religion that we had at your Ranch a booth there last November. And then there's also another gentleman, you mentioned And you brought it up in your book. But Whitehead was also, very revolutionary and taking the religious argument and also talking about why evil exists, can you share us a little bit about whiteheads? Viewpoint in his theodicy Whitehead? Alfred North Whitehead was a mathematician and genius who can who moved over from mathematics at the very highest level in the world really to philosophy and He and Bertrand Russell wrote the primary text on mathematics in the night around 1910.
15:09 And so he then came in philosophy when he left England and and I went to Harvard. So he wanted to Think Through logically the prob these problems and problem of evil and many other problems and came up with this notion that deity evolves. And that's really kind of unprecedented, but there was a sense of that Century earlier in hegel's philosophy. And his school of thought has a huge Wing that states that school. Open theism was very interesting modern wing and kind of the comes out of that white heady and view that says, well God could do that, but God is self restraining and doesn't do that and less there are, you know, very sort of cosmic and And critical reasons which is basically the you the Urantia Book View as well about that. So but but white heady and reject the idea of omnipotence and you need to be an omnipotent deity to really do interventions that are efficacious.
16:16 So they say that God is not controlling in that way. But God is initiating. Why his agency known as primordial deity. This part of the city that has the ability to initiate. E8 Evolution. And so in a way it's a commentary on darwinian Theory but it's but it's a more philosophical theological to how does this come into being? Well, there's a Creator deity, that brings it into being, but the deity doesn't have powers but the deity doesn't control it. But rather is a deity of persuasion that the deity provides ways of once rational hominid, hominids become rational, they Or can be persuaded by various agencies of deity, which which they, which are fairly limited for them.
17:07 For example, they don't really think of of an incarnation of the second person of the Trinity that they don't see it that way, that that it's some of them do, but, but Whitehead didn't than that, it wasn't, it wasn't according to the Christian view that God has become incarnate in order to persuade us, but they have the view that God is. Inside you and that that's how evolution is taking place but not through these external agencies at that omnipotent deities able to use, but it's still a beautiful, beautiful notion because that is the idea more or less of the Supreme Being, who do you think you really were just went? Wow, that was a brilliant, you know, thinker Who impressed you the most?
17:56 I think that Whitehead is really near the top but what I did do in the book is I chose this set of the very best of them seven or eight and all of them are kind of equally very profound but partial And I say that because the conclusion of the book is is stating these seven or eight, great ideas are all to be found in the you be in other words, a UB also located these ideas and then Incorporated them as human sources yet has to be because there's some times it is like with other human sources.
18:43 There's a this like a paraphrasing that's pretty. Direct for example Luther is one of the yeah, one of the seventh or eighth grade and Luther's justification by faith is almost literally quoted word for word in the words of Jesus in the Rancher book. And that is part of theodicy. It's a partial view. It's a view having to do with the individuals, individuals, interior, moral life, and the kind of surrender and acceptance of ones that want to saved by faith. And so, so that's an example. Will you be borrowing as a human Source from loser? But it but I argue that, you know, they have they have an Olympian knowledge of human theology, the revelator's and and so they're going to Echo the greatest thinkers and seen augustin's one of them obviously acquaintances another but these more modern 19th century early 20th century, they are echoing Whitehead and very distinct ways.
19:44 But also a number of other All the ones in a way is Central to the UB Zone, native theodicy, which we see in the, you know, statement on the inevitability. He's on page 52. I don't think I would have been able to appreciate your book and I recognize that the your auntie book has really broadened, my understanding of spirituality, more than I expected. Were you pleased? That the Urantia book was consistent. I didn't quite recognize that till you know, later later on first. I was like a lot of the ranch of readers that. Well this is all new. This is totally out of the blue. This is pure Revelation, never been surpassed but but what I think the more mature view is that you realize oh my God.
20:31 This is this is actually in conversation with these great thinkers of the past in our tradition and literally alludes to many of them. I would add here about about Saint Augustine who made some big mistakes but also hit some very Three high points in his notion of what they call. The Free Will defense of God's goodness. And how this guy could have come up with this is, you know, it's the spirit of Truth moving through him. But we have to remember always with these human sources that they are, they are, they are inhibited by their cultural context. And in the next episode, we will continue our discussion with Byron.
21:17 And talk about the state of today's religion. How Christians can help in the Urantia book movement, and just how much Byron believes? The luciferian influence is, impacting current times, look for part two, on the Rancher Radio podcast.